The College Swimming & Diving Coaches Association of America (CSCAA) has named over 2,230 swimmers and divers to its Scholar All-American Team presented by Fitter & Faster Swim Camps for the 2025-26 season. The Luther College women's swimming and diving team had three honorees including Mia Prater, Kate Denner and Noelle Gallucci. Prater received first-team Scholar All-America honors while Denner and Gallucci were second-team selections.
 
Prater is now a three-time Scholar All-American earning first-team honors in 2024 and second team honors in 2025. At the American Rivers Conference (A-R-C) championship she was named the swimmer of the meet and went on to represent the Norse at the NCAA Division III national championship. In the 50 freestyle event she earned honorable mention All-American honors by finishing 15^th.
 
Denner earned her second Scholar All-American honors of her career marking her first since 2024. She was a runner-up in the 1-meter diving competition at the A-R-C championship.
 
In her first season with the Norse, Gallucci earns her first Scholar All-American honors. Gallucci earned the title of diver of the meet at the A-R-C championship after winning titles on the 1-meter and 3-meter boards.
 
To qualify for first-team Scholar All-America, student-athletes must have earned a GPA of 3.5 or higher and participated in their national championship. Second-Team selections, must have also earned a 3.5 GPA or higher and an NCAA "B" qualifying standard for the national championship or qualified for a diving zone qualification meet.